Sub choices-seeking opinions

Kid Red · Post by **Kid Red** » Wed Jan 24, 2007 8:47 am

cargodz wrote:Recommended:
0.75-1.0 cu. ft. sealed
1.0-1.5 cu. ft. ported

Now given that range, which would you say would be the optimal sealed size? If I go 1 cu ft, then I have to make it bigger for the speaker displacement, etc and I don't get a lot of wiggle room. I'd go .75 nicely, over that and it gets tight. Of course, there's always polyfill....

Kid Red · Post by **Kid Red** » Wed Jan 24, 2007 8:49 am

neumann wrote:Those ones on ebay with the arc in the white letters are about 3 years old if you care to know.

Whoa, lol. Thanks man. Yea, I'd much rather not use eBay because of reasons just like that.

cargodz · Post by **cargodz** » Wed Jan 24, 2007 9:20 am

If you go to Massive Audio you can download the pdf version of the manual for the RW series, but I'll save you the trouble... here ya go: http://www.massiveaudio.com/lowband/products/subwoofers/reference/rw-boxinstruction-stg2.pdf

cargodz · Post by **cargodz** » Wed Jan 24, 2007 9:27 am

Kid Red, You got a PM

sinister audio · Post by **sinister audio** » Wed Jan 24, 2007 11:07 am

id go with the arcs, eclipse, or tcs. probaly the eclipse first.

Kid Red · Post by **Kid Red** » Wed Jan 24, 2007 11:40 am

thanks cargodz, you got one too :)

Ah, finally a vote for Eclipse. I had begun to second guess my inclusion of the Eclipse. This is tuff deciding and comparing without auditioning, lol

Kid Red · Post by **Kid Red** » Wed Jan 24, 2007 12:54 pm

Oooh, just saw the Assassin 10 for $70!? Whoa, but their website said unavailable. Any comments on assassins and where I can buy them? It's a single 4 ohm, so should work with my current amp.

Kid Red · Post by **Kid Red** » Wed Jan 24, 2007 4:25 pm

Ok, I've researched a ton of names I've never heard of, all from the highly recommended listing. I'd like to know what the best choice is for SQ and low bass. Not really concerned with SPL, but I want to be able to hear it, feel it and enjoy it :)

My tentative ranking based on what I can find, price, looks and specs-

Arc Audio ARC 10D2 250w (pending price)
Ascendant Audio assassin 10 $70
Massive Audio RW10 $120 400w
Oz audio vector series 10.3 $139, 350w
Elevation Audio comp 10 $99 300w
Elemental Designs 11kv.2 $115
Memphis MClass 15-MS104 (local dealer $140)
CDT EF-100 (did not like the cheap mounting ring) $90
Eclipse SW6000 300w $99 (not sure I can find a D2)
Diamond Audio D310D2 $99

Now, if either of these is a must have above the previous mentioned, I may splurge-

TC sounds TC-1000 $179
sound splinter RL-i $170

Any comments, lol. I can't seem to narrow it down because I have little knowledge or experience with any of these. I'd have to be able to purchase online because there aren't many dealers locally. At least give me like the top 2-3 and I can enie menie minie moe, haha. Seriously, if these are all equal, to me it would then be price/looks to decide.

swimmerdude · Post by **swimmerdude** » Wed Jan 24, 2007 5:34 pm

Kid Red wrote:Ok, I've researched a ton of names I've never heard of, all from the highly recommended listing. I'd like to know what the best choice is for SQ and low bass. Not really concerned with SPL, but I want to be able to hear it, feel it and enjoy it :)

My tentative ranking based on what I can find, price, looks and specs-

Arc Audio ARC 10D2 250w (pending price)
Ascendant Audio assassin 10 $70
Massive Audio RW10 $120 400w
Oz audio vector series 10.3 $139, 350w
Elevation Audio comp 10 $99 300w
Elemental Designs 11kv.2 $115
Memphis MClass 15-MS104 (local dealer $140)
CDT EF-100 (did not like the cheap mounting ring) $90
Eclipse SW6000 300w $99 (not sure I can find a D2)
Diamond Audio D310D2 $99

I would cross off the second half of the list after the elemental designs. And just in case you didnt see, the Massive Audio only comes in dual 4ohm coils. Diamond's site is down right now, so i couldnt read up on their specs at all.

After doing a little reading on the specs of the subs and playing in winisd... i would have to make my list like this...

Arc Audio ARC
Elevation Comp
Ascendant Assassin
OZ Vector
Massive RW

All of the subs are going to have around the same SQ and output. The only thing i see is that the Ascendant and the Massive will fall a little behind in output over the others because they are a little less efficient. I don't know the price tag on the Arc, but i would choose between the Arc, Elevation, and Ascendant. The Ascendant is by far cheaper, so less money spent for what you are getting. The Arc on the other hand i think will be quite a bit more expensive that the others, but that price tag comes with it being a pure sq woofer.

Kid Red · Post by **Kid Red** » Wed Jan 24, 2007 5:52 pm

Dude, you rock. That was exactly the type of response I was hoping for and I appreciate the time you spent coming to your conclusion. I wasn't sure about the MA being a D4 only, so I included it just in case.

So Arc, Elevation then AA in order of preference, then apply my budget and looks. What price do you think the Arc price range ball park is? The guys there are emailing me back but I just have no idea what to expect. Would you still have Arc Audio first if it was a FD or KAR sub? How do the FD and Kar subs compare to the Assassin and Elevation Comp? If between Elevation and Assassin, I think I'd go Assassin.

The Elevation looks cool, but those ridges or something on the cone look clunky. Do you know where I can find some nice close up pics of the Elevation? Maybe the small jpgs are making it look worse than it is.